Filter Types Explained: Which One Is Right for You?

There are four main types of water filters for UK homes: activated carbon, reverse osmosis, UV, and water softeners. Each removes different contaminants, costs different amounts, and solves different problems. Here's everything you need to know to choose the right one. All removal rates are based on NSF International testing standards. New to water filtration? Start with the basics.

Quick Comparison

FeatureActivated CarbonReverse Osmosis (RO)CeramicUV SterilizerWater Softener
Best ForChlorine, taste, odorLead, PFAS, microplasticsBacteria, cysts, off-gridBacteria, virusesHard water, limescale
Upfront Cost£50-200£250-500£150-300£150-400£400-1,500
Annual Running Cost£30-60£54-120£60-120£20-40£80-150
Pressure RequiredAny (1+ bar)High (3+ bar)None (gravity) or 1+ barAny (1+ bar)Any (1+ bar)
Wastes WaterNoYes (4:1 ratio)NoNoYes (regeneration)
MaintenanceEasy (replace every 6-12 months)Moderate (multiple filters)Moderate (clean monthly, replace 6 months)Easy (bulb yearly)Moderate (salt refills)
InstallationDIY friendlyProfessional recommendedDIY friendly (gravity) or moderate (under-sink)DIY friendlyProfessional required

Activated Carbon Filters

The most common and affordable option

How It Works

Activated carbon is charcoal that's been treated to create millions of tiny pores. Water flows through these pores, and contaminants stick to the carbon surface through a process called adsorption. Think of it like a molecular sponge—chemicals and particles get trapped while water passes through. Effectiveness varies based on NSF certification level.

What It Removes

  • Chlorine: 95-99% removal (taste and odor)
  • VOCs: 85-95% (volatile organic compounds)
  • Pesticides: 70-90% removal
  • Some PFAS: 40-70% (longer-chain PFAS only)
  • Sediment: Particles larger than filter pore size

What It Doesn't Remove

  • Lead: Minimal removal (need special carbon block)
  • Fluoride: Not removed
  • Nitrates: Not removed
  • Bacteria/Viruses: Not removed
  • Hard water minerals: Not removed
  • Microplastics: Depends on pore size (most pass through)

Best For:

Households primarily concerned about chlorine taste/odor, or those in areas with good baseline water quality who want to improve taste. Ideal for renters or those on a budget. Perfect for London and South East England where chlorine levels are high.

Not Suitable For:

Pre-1970 homes with lead pipes, areas with bacterial contamination, or households concerned about PFAS/microplastics. Carbon filters won't solve hard water problems or protect against heavy metals.

Total Cost of Ownership (10 Years)

Initial cost: £50-200 (filter + installation)

Replacement filters: £30-60/year × 10 years = £300-600

Total 10-year cost: £350-800

Reverse Osmosis (RO) Systems

The most comprehensive filtration

How It Works

RO systems force water through a semi-permeable membrane with pores 0.0001 microns wide—1,000 times smaller than a human hair, small enough to block virtually everything except water molecules. It's like pushing water through an incredibly fine mesh that catches contaminants at the molecular level.

What It Removes

  • Lead: 95-99% removal
  • PFAS: 90-99% removal (all types)
  • Microplastics: 99%+ removal
  • Fluoride: 85-95% removal
  • Nitrates: 85-95% removal
  • Arsenic: 95-99% removal
  • Chlorine: 99% removal
  • Bacteria/Viruses: 99.9% removal

Important Limitations

  • !Wastes water: 4 litres wasted per 1 litre filtered
  • !High pressure needed: 40+ PSI (3+ bar) minimum
  • !Slow flow rate: Takes time to fill a glass
  • !Removes minerals: Water tastes "flat" (some systems add back)
  • !Complex maintenance: Multiple filters to replace
  • !Doesn't soften water: Won't solve limescale problems

PFAS & Microplastics: The Testing Gap

At the time of writing, no home testing kits exist for PFAS or microplastics. These contaminants require specialized laboratory equipment to detect.

Scotland has mandatory PFAS testing (0.1 µg/L limit) since January 2023. England has voluntary guidelines only. You can contact your water company to ask about their PFAS testing frequency and results—find contact details via Ofwat.

For removal: Reverse osmosis is the gold standard—90-99% PFAS removal, 99%+ microplastics removal. Specialized activated carbon can remove 50-90% of PFAS, but standard carbon filters provide minimal removal (10-30%).

Best For:

Pre-1970 homes with lead pipes, households concerned about PFAS/microplastics, areas with agricultural runoff (nitrates), or anyone wanting the most comprehensive filtration. Particularly valuable for unmetered households (37.3% of UK) where waste water costs nothing. Ideal for families with young children or immunocompromised members.

Not Suitable For:

Top-floor flats with low water pressure (unless you install a £180-600 booster pump), metered households on a tight budget (waste water adds £54-108/year), or those who need high flow rates for cooking. Won't solve hard water/limescale problems—you'd need a softener too.

Total Cost of Ownership (10 Years)

Unmetered Household:

Initial cost: £350-700 (system + installation)

Replacement filters: £60-100/year × 10 years = £600-1,000

Waste water: £0

Total 10-year cost: £950-1,700

Metered Household:

Initial cost: £350-700

Replacement filters: £600-1,000

Waste water: £54-108/year × 10 years = £540-1,080

Total 10-year cost: £1,490-2,780

UV Sterilizers

Kills bacteria and viruses without chemicals

How It Works

UV sterilizers expose water to ultraviolet light at 254 nanometers wavelength, which damages the DNA of bacteria, viruses, and other microorganisms, preventing them from reproducing. The water flows past a UV bulb in a chamber—no chemicals, no filters to replace (just the bulb annually).

What It Removes

  • Bacteria: 99.99% kill rate (E. coli, Salmonella, etc.)
  • Viruses: 99.99% inactivation
  • Cryptosporidium: 99.9% (like Brixham outbreak 2024)
  • Giardia: 99.9% inactivation

What It Doesn't Remove

  • Chemicals: Chlorine, PFAS, pesticides pass through
  • Heavy metals: Lead, arsenic not removed
  • Sediment: Particles pass through
  • Taste/odor: Doesn't improve taste
  • Hard water: Minerals not removed
  • Microplastics: Not removed

Best For:

Private wells, rural areas with bacterial concerns, or as a backup during boil water notices. Often combined with carbon or RO systems for comprehensive protection. Useful in areas prone to contamination incidents like the Brixham cryptosporidium outbreak (May 2024).

Not Suitable For:

Mains water in areas with good baseline quality (UK mains water is already 99.98% compliant when it leaves treatment works). UV doesn't improve taste, remove chemicals, or solve hard water problems. Most UK households don't need UV unless they have a private well or specific contamination concerns.

Total Cost of Ownership (10 Years)

Initial cost: £150-400 (unit + installation)

UV bulb replacement: £20-40/year × 10 years = £200-400

Electricity: £15-25/year × 10 years = £150-250

Total 10-year cost: £500-1,050

Water Softeners

Removes hard water minerals (calcium, magnesium)

How It Works

Water softeners use ion exchange resin beads that swap calcium and magnesium ions (hard water minerals) for sodium ions. The resin eventually becomes saturated and needs regeneration—flushing with salt water to recharge the beads. This is a whole-house system, not point-of-use.

What It Removes

  • Calcium: 95-99% removal
  • Magnesium: 95-99% removal
  • Some iron: Depends on type
  • Some manganese: Partial removal

Benefits: No limescale buildup on taps, kettles, appliances. Softer skin and hair. Less soap and detergent needed. Longer appliance lifespan.

What It Doesn't Remove

  • Chlorine: Not removed
  • Lead: Not removed
  • PFAS: Not removed
  • Bacteria/Viruses: Not removed
  • Microplastics: Not removed
  • Nitrates: Not removed

Important: Softened water contains more sodium (salt is used in the ion exchange process to replace calcium and magnesium). Thames Water advises against drinking softened water, especially for babies and those on low-sodium diets. Excess sodium can contribute to high blood pressure and cardiovascular issues in sensitive individuals. If you have a softener, install a separate tap for drinking water or use an RO filter (which removes sodium).

Best For:

Hard water areas (London, South East, East Anglia) where limescale is a major problem. Protects appliances (washing machines, dishwashers, boilers), reduces cleaning time, and improves skin/hair feel. Often combined with a drinking water filter (carbon or RO) for comprehensive protection.

Not Suitable For:

Soft water areas (Scotland, North West England, Wales) where hardness isn't a problem. Renters (requires professional installation and plumbing modifications). Those on low-sodium diets. Doesn't improve drinking water safety or taste—you'd need a separate drinking water filter.

Total Cost of Ownership (10 Years)

Initial cost: £400-1,500 (system + professional installation)

Salt: £80-120/year × 10 years = £800-1,200

Electricity: £15-30/year × 10 years = £150-300

Maintenance: £50-100/year × 10 years = £500-1,000

Total 10-year cost: £1,850-4,000

Note: Savings from reduced appliance repairs and longer lifespan can offset costs over time.

Which Filter Is Right for You?

1

Do you have hard water (London, South East, East Anglia)?

Water Softener for whole house + Carbon or RO for drinking water

2

Do you have lead pipes (pre-1970 home)?

Reverse Osmosis (100% lead removal - TechGearLab verified)

3

Concerned about PFAS or microplastics?

Reverse Osmosis (90-99% PFAS, 99%+ microplastics)

4

Just want to improve chlorine taste/odor?

Activated Carbon (cheapest, simplest solution)

5

Private well or bacterial concerns?

UV Sterilizer + Carbon or RO for chemicals

6

Want comprehensive protection?

RO System (removes virtually everything) or Carbon + UV combination

Regional Recommendations

London & South East

Water characteristics: Very hard (300+ mg/L), high chlorine, potential lead pipes in older areas—check your postcode

Recommended:

  • Water softener for whole house (limescale protection)
  • RO system for drinking water (lead + PFAS + microplastics)
  • Or carbon filter if budget-conscious (chlorine taste only)

Manchester & North West

Water characteristics: Soft water, potential copper/lead leaching in old pipes

Recommended:

  • RO system if pre-1970 home (lead/copper removal)
  • Carbon filter for chlorine taste (most common need)
  • No softener needed (water already soft)

Scotland

Water characteristics: Very soft, excellent baseline quality, mostly unmetered

Recommended:

  • RO system if concerned about PFAS/microplastics (unmetered = free waste water)
  • Carbon filter for taste improvement (minimal need)
  • Most households don't need filtration

East Anglia & Yorkshire

Water characteristics: Hard water, agricultural runoff (nitrates), some lead pipes

Recommended:

  • Water softener for hard water (whole house)
  • RO system for drinking water (nitrates + lead + PFAS)
  • Carbon filter if budget-conscious (taste only)

Ceramic Water Filters

Natural filtration for gravity systems and countertops

How It Works

Ceramic water filters use microporous ceramic material (diatomaceous earth) to physically filter out contaminants. The tiny pores (0.5-0.9 microns absolute) trap bacteria, protozoa, sediment, and particles—think of it as a 3D sieve that catches anything too large to pass through. Many ceramic filters include an activated carbon core for improved taste and chemical reduction, plus optional media for lead, fluoride, or heavy metals. Doulton and British Berkefeld are the main UK manufacturers with NSF certification.

What It Removes

  • Bacteria: >99.99% removal (E.coli, Typhoid, Salmonella)
  • Cysts: >99.99% (Giardia, Cryptosporidium)
  • Chlorine: >99% removal (with carbon core)
  • Microplastics: >99.9% removal (NSF 401)
  • PFAS: 95% removal (with GAC core, PFOA+PFOS)
  • Lead: Up to 95% reduction (with lead removal media)
  • Sediment: Rust, dirt, particles >0.5 micron

What It Doesn't Remove

  • Viruses: Limited removal (pores too large for most viruses)
  • Fluoride: Not removed (unless fluoride media added)
  • TDS/Hard water: Doesn't remove dissolved minerals
  • Nitrates: Not removed
  • Slow flow rate: Gravity systems: 1L/hour per filter

Best For:

Off-grid living, well water users, emergency preparedness (no electricity needed), and renters who prefer countertop gravity systems. Ideal for microbiologically unsafe water (bacteria, cysts) or those who want natural materials over plastic. Popular UK brands include Doulton (Staffordshire-based, 200-year heritage) and British Berkefeld.

Limitations:

Slow flow rate (gravity systems: 1L/hour per filter), requires regular cleaning (scrub ceramic shell monthly to maintain flow), fragile (ceramic can crack if dropped), and doesn't remove viruses (pores too large at 0.5 micron). Gravity systems need countertop space. Not ideal for hard water areas (doesn't remove TDS/hardness).

Certifications

British Berkefeld Ultra Sterasyl filters are NSF 42, 53, 372, and 401 certified—one of the few gravity filters with comprehensive certification. Doulton filters are NSF 42/53 certified and WRAS approved for UK plumbing compliance. Always verify certification in the NSF database before purchasing.

Total Cost of Ownership (10 Years)

Initial cost: £150-300 (gravity system with 2 filters)

Replacement cartridges: £60-120/year × 10 years = £600-1,200

Electricity: £0 (gravity systems)

Water waste: £0 (no waste water)

Total 10-year cost: £750-1,500

Cost per litre: 0.3-0.6p (based on 2,300L per cartridge)

Market Reality

Ceramic filters are a niche but active market in the UK. Amazon UK sells approximately 3,000 ceramic filter units monthly, primarily for gravity systems (British Berkefeld, Doulton) and replacement cartridges. They're more popular than you might expect, especially among the off-grid and preparedness communities. Cleanable/reusable ceramic shells make them cost-effective for long-term use.

Water Softeners + RO Systems: Why You Need Both

Critical information for hard water areas

⚠️ Critical: Hard Water Reduces RO Membrane Lifespan by 30%

If you live in a hard water area (London, Southeast, East Anglia, Yorkshire) and install an RO system WITHOUT a water softener, you're setting yourself up for expensive filter replacements. Hard water contains calcium and magnesium that form limescale, clogging your RO membrane and reducing its lifespan from 4-5 years to just 2-3 years—or even 12-18 months in very hard water areas.

Why Water Softeners Protect RO Systems

RO membranes have microscopic pores (0.0001 microns) that are incredibly sensitive to scale buildup. When hard water passes through, calcium and magnesium crystallize on the membrane surface, clogging pores and reducing flow rate. The membrane has to work harder, uses more water, and eventually fails prematurely.

A water softener removes calcium and magnesium BEFORE they reach the RO membrane, protecting it from scale damage. The RO system then removes the small amount of sodium added by the softener, giving you pure, soft, sodium-free drinking water.

Installation Order (Critical)

✅ Correct Order:

Mains Water → Water Softener → RO System → Drinking Tap

❌ Wrong Order:

Mains Water → RO System → Water Softener (Don't do this!)

When You NEED a Softener Before RO

  • Above 200 ppm (very hard): Softener is ESSENTIAL (London, Southeast, East Anglia)
  • 150-200 ppm (hard): Softener is HIGHLY RECOMMENDED (Yorkshire, Midlands)
  • 100-150 ppm (moderately hard): Softener is RECOMMENDED (extends RO lifespan)
  • Below 100 ppm (soft): Softener is OPTIONAL (Scotland, Northwest, Wales)

Use our Water Quality Lookup Tool to check your local water hardness.

Cost Savings with Softener

RO Membrane Lifespan (Hard Water):

  • Without softener: 2-3 years (£50-150 replacement every 2-3 years)
  • With softener: 4-5 years (£50-150 replacement every 4-5 years)

Annual Savings: £50-100/year on RO filter replacements alone

Plus: Protected appliances (boiler, washing machine, dishwasher), no limescale buildup, softer skin/hair

Bottom Line:

If you have hard water (>150 ppm) and want an RO system, budget for BOTH a water softener (£400-1,500) and RO system (£250-500). Installing RO alone in hard water areas is a false economy—you'll spend more on premature filter replacements than you saved by skipping the softener.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

❌ Buying RO without checking water pressure

RO systems need 40+ PSI (3+ bar) to work. Top-floor flats often have 1-2 bar. Test your pressure first or you'll need a £180-600 booster pump. Read our complete RO cost guide.

❌ Expecting carbon filters to remove lead

Carbon filters only remove 3.8% of lead (TechGearLab verified) - not effective for lead concerns. They DO remove 93% of PFAS, which is good. For lead pipes, you need RO (100% lead removal).

❌ Installing a softener in soft water areas

Scotland, North West England, and Wales already have soft water. A softener won't help and adds unnecessary sodium to your water.

❌ Ignoring RO waste water costs if you're metered

RO wastes 4 litres per 1 litre filtered. If you're metered, that's £54-108/year extra on your water bill. Factor this into your decision. See full cost breakdown.

❌ Thinking UV sterilizers improve taste or remove chemicals

UV only kills microorganisms. It doesn't remove chlorine, improve taste, or protect against chemicals. Most UK mains water doesn't need UV.

❌ Not replacing filters on schedule

Expired filters don't just stop working—they can release trapped contaminants back into your water. Set calendar reminders for replacements.

Still Not Sure Which Filter You Need?

Take our interactive quiz to get personalized recommendations based on your location, water quality, and specific concerns.

Lead in UK Water: Essential Reading

Lead is the #1 water quality concern in UK homes built before 1970. These guides will help you understand the risks and solutions.

Need a Quick Solution?

See our filtration ladder to find the right level of protection for your home—from basic taste improvement to complete contaminant removal.